Form of Business Organization: Which Should You Choose?

The two tax systems and the main entity types

Every business falls under one of two federal tax systems. C-corporations face what's sometimes called the corporate double tax: the entity itself is taxed on its income, and then owners are taxed again on dividends or other profit they receive. Pass through entities work differently. The entity itself isn't taxed; instead, each owner is taxed directly on their proportionate share of the entity's income. Partnerships, S-corporations, and limited liability companies are the leading pass through forms, and a sole proprietorship counts as a pass through entity too, even though no formal organization may be involved.

The first major decision is whether to accept two levels of tax (a C-corp) or stick to one level directly on the owners (a pass through entity). Losses matter here too: pass through owners can generally deduct losses directly, while C-corp losses only offset the corporation's own past or future profits and don't pass through to owners. That's part of why new businesses expecting startup losses are often advised to begin as pass through entities, so owners can use those losses against other income right away.

Separately from tax considerations, there's the business question of liability. State law grants limited liability to corporations, LLCs, and certain partners in specific partnership structures, generally capping your exposure at your actual or promised investment in the business.

Back to top

Choosing the tax treatment

Since 1997, the IRS has allowed a meaningful degree of choice in how an entity is taxed federally, commonly called "check the box." A few combinations aren't allowed: incorporated entities must be taxed as corporations (though an S-corp election may still be available), and publicly traded partnerships or LLCs must be taxed as C-corps. Foreign entities follow their own special rules.

Most other partnerships can choose C-corp or pass through treatment. An LLC with two or more members can choose C-corp, partnership, or S-corp treatment; a single member LLC can choose C-corp or S-corp treatment, or simply be disregarded, in which case the owner is taxed directly, similar to a sole proprietorship.

Changing your election has consequences. Switching from corporate to partnership treatment, for example, is treated as liquidating the corporation for tax purposes. Most states that impose corporate taxes follow your federal check the box choice, though not always with identical results, and your federal tax election doesn't automatically change how the entity is classified under state business law.

Back to top

Choosing the form itself

Once you understand the tax mechanics, the next question is which form actually fits how you want to run the business and handle profits or startup losses. Some decisions are driven by business needs rather than tax outcomes: if you plan to have interests publicly traded, only the C-corp works, and certain regulated activities, banking, for instance, may require the corporate form by law.

From a tax standpoint, C-corps carry two levels of tax, but the first (at the corporate level) can be lower than what you'd pay personally, and the second (at the owner level) is often deferred until dividends or other assets are actually distributed. Distributing appreciated assets, or selling them and distributing the proceeds, is now taxable at both the corporate and owner level, closing off what used to be a way to avoid double taxation. Funds can also build up inside a C-corp at a comparatively low rate until distributed, though the eventual combined tax, corporate plus owner level, can end up higher than a single pass through tax would have been.

A C-corp can reduce its own tax by paying out income as compensation and fringe benefits to owner employees, which approximates pass through treatment since the corporation deducts what it pays and only the recipients are taxed. This works especially well in personal service businesses. The IRS can push back if it considers owner compensation "unreasonable," treating part of it as a nondeductible profit distribution instead. In short, some businesses need C-corp status for business reasons, but it's comparatively rare for it to be the better tax choice for a brand new business.

Back to top

Choosing among pass through entities

If a pass through entity makes sense for you, you still have several options, each with its own tradeoffs.

S-corporations offer limited liability, an advantage over general partnerships, sole proprietorships, and LLCs in states that don't allow single member LLCs. That protection comes with real restrictions: all owners must agree to S-corp status, only one class of stock is allowed, ownership is capped (generally at 100, with certain family members counted together), and there are limits on who can be an owner and what kind of business can qualify. Failing to meet these requirements converts the entity to C-corp status and C-corp taxation.

LLCs versus S-corps share the same core business advantage, limited liability, but LLCs generally offer more tax flexibility, since they can choose partnership tax treatment. That flexibility shows up in several ways: LLCs can allocate income, deductions, and other tax attributes disproportionately among members, in a way S-corps can't due to the single class of stock rule; LLC members can deduct losses beyond their own investment, up to their share of LLC debt, while S-corp owners are limited to their investment plus any debt the S-corp owes them directly; adding new LLC members and transferring appreciated property into an LLC is generally easier and more tax efficient than the comparable transaction with an S-corp.

LLCs versus partnerships come down mainly to liability: LLCs offer limited liability to all members, which general and limited partnerships don't fully provide. Federal tax treatment is largely similar between the two, though partnerships have some partner specific rules, particularly around self employment tax, that may or may not extend to LLC members depending on their role.

LLCs versus sole proprietorships favor the LLC on liability grounds, since a sole proprietor has no separate liability shield at all. A single member LLC can elect to be disregarded for tax purposes, meaning the owner is taxed directly as if the LLC didn't exist, while still keeping the liability protection intact under state law.

Back to top

Professional practice entities

Professionals like doctors and lawyers have a few specialized options. Professional corporations provide limited liability for general business debts but not for the professional's own malpractice, and in some states, not for a colleague's malpractice either; they can be structured as C-corps or S-corps. Most states also allow professionals to organize as LLCs or professional limited liability companies, which similarly don't shield you from your own malpractice but may limit exposure to a colleague's malpractice or other firm debts, depending on the state.

Limited liability partnerships were designed specifically for professional practices: a partner is liable for their own malpractice but not, typically, a partner's malpractice or other partnership acts, though state law usually requires maintaining malpractice insurance and paying a per partner fee to keep that status. Some practitioners choose to remain sole proprietors or general partners instead, reasoning that their real exposure is malpractice risk, which a limited liability entity doesn't protect against anyway, and rely on malpractice insurance as their actual protection.

Back to top

Other pros and cons of C-corps

C-corps have a real advantage on fringe benefits: owner employees of a C-corp qualify for certain benefits that self employed people, partners, LLC members, sole proprietors, and more than 2 percent S-corp shareholders don't. Health insurance, for example, can be entirely tax free to a C-corp owner employee, while it's only partly tax free for the self employed, due to more limited deduction rules for that group.

C-corps are also somewhat less exposed to passive loss deduction limits, which restrict deducting losses from activities you don't materially participate in against other income; limited partners tend to be hit hardest by these limits. On the downside, C-corps face tighter restrictions on using the cash method of accounting, which generally defers tax compared to the accrual method, so this is a real disadvantage worth weighing against the fringe benefit and passive loss advantages.

Back to top

A closer look at S-corps

An otherwise qualifying, generally nontaxable S-corp can still owe corporate level tax on specific items without losing its S status entirely. This happens when a former C-corp converts to S-corp status and later sells appreciated property it carried over from its C-corp days, or when an S-corp earns excessive passive investment income (interest, dividends, and similar income above 25 percent of gross receipts, since S-corps are meant to be operating companies rather than holding companies).

Some business owners look at S-corp status partly as a way to manage employment tax. A sole proprietor earning $120,000, for instance, might convert to an S-corp and split that into $70,000 in wages and $50,000 in dividends; income tax stays roughly the same, but the dividend portion generally escapes employment tax. In cases where little or no wages were paid relative to dividends, the IRS has reclassified dividends as wages subject to employment tax, but where substantial wages accompany substantial dividends, this structure has generally held up.

Back to top

Changing to another entity

The advantages of LLCs have led many business owners to convert existing entities into that form, though other conversions make sense in specific situations too, a general partnership becoming an LLP for liability reasons, or a C-corp becoming an S-corp for tax reasons. Any check the box election is treated, for federal tax purposes, as an actual change of entity, regardless of what happens under state business law.

Broadly, here's what typically happens: converting between C-corp and S-corp status triggers no tax on the conversion itself, with pass through treatment applying while S status is in effect. Converting a corporation to an LLC, partnership, or sole proprietorship generally triggers tax on the liquidation of the corporation. Converting between partnership and LLC, or between sole proprietorship and single member LLC, triggers no tax and pass through treatment continues uninterrupted. Converting an LLC, partnership, or sole proprietorship into a C-corp or S-corp generally triggers no tax on the conversion itself. Every one of these has real complexity behind it, so review your specific situation with a tax advisor before acting.

Back to top