Charitable Contributions: How to Give Wisely

Basic precautions for any donation

A few habits protect you regardless of how you're asked to give. Pay by check or money order made out to the charity itself, never cash, and never to an individual soliciting on the charity's behalf. Watch for names that closely resemble well-known organizations; similarity isn't verification. Resist pressure to decide immediately; a legitimate charity will still be legitimate tomorrow. For anything substantial, ask for written information about the charity's programs and finances before committing, and if you have any doubt, check with your state's charity registration office (usually part of the attorney general's office) or the Better Business Bureau. Keep receipts, canceled checks, and bank statements for everything you give, since you'll need them at tax time regardless of amount.

Back to top

Giving your time instead of money

Volunteering can be genuinely rewarding, but it's worth treating like any other commitment. Get familiar with the organization's actual activities and ask for written program and financial information before committing. Some volunteer roles require training or a set weekly time commitment, so make sure that's realistic for you. If you're considering door-to-door fundraising on a charity's behalf, confirm it has real financial controls in place over collected funds. The value of your own time isn't deductible, but out-of-pocket costs you incur while volunteering, including transportation, generally are.

Back to top

Mail, phone, and door-to-door solicitations

Most direct mail appeals are honest, but a few red flags are worth knowing. A legitimate mailing clearly identifies the charity and describes its programs in specifics; an appeal heavy on emotion and light on actual function deserves a closer look. It's illegal to demand payment for unsolicited merchandise like address labels or greeting cards sent along with an appeal; you're under no obligation to pay for or return them. Sweepstakes-style appeals must disclose that no donation is required to enter, and appeals disguised as bills or invoices are illegal without a clear disclaimer.

Phone and door-to-door solicitors should welcome your questions, not resist them. Ask for the charity's full name and address, whether your contribution is actually tax-deductible (not all tax-exempt organizations qualify), and whether the charity is properly registered in your state. Don't let anyone rush you into an immediate decision or send a runner to collect on the spot, and be skeptical of vague promises that "all proceeds" go to the cause, since that phrase often means what's left after fundraising costs, which can be substantial.

Back to top

Events, thrift stores, and affinity cards

Tickets to charity dinners, galas, or shows are only partly deductible, generally just the amount above the fair market value of what you receive, and that's true even if you give the tickets away instead of using them. If you don't plan to attend, returning the tickets to the charity rather than keeping them lets you deduct the full payment.

Thrift stores operate differently depending on the charity: some are run directly by the organization, others by service groups like the Salvation Army as part of broader program work, and some simply collect donated goods to sell through independently managed stores for an agreed fee. The fair market value of goods donated to a genuine charity-operated thrift store is deductible; goods donated to a for-profit thrift operation, or sold on consignment where you receive a percentage, are not.

Affinity credit cards bearing a charity's name and logo vary widely in how much actually benefits the cause, sometimes a percentage of each purchase, sometimes a flat signup fee, sometimes a slice of the annual renewal fee. Read the specific terms rather than assuming, and note that contributions made by the bank or card company through card usage aren't deductible to you personally, since you didn't make them.

Back to top

Disaster appeals and other special cases

Natural disasters reliably bring out both genuine relief efforts and opportunistic fraud. Take time to compare options rather than giving to the first appeal you see, and ask specifically how much of your gift addresses the immediate crisis versus ongoing programs or administrative costs. For overseas disaster relief, check with the organization before donating physical goods; many groups prefer cash since purchasing supplies locally is often more efficient than shipping donated items.

Police and firefighter appeals deserve particular scrutiny, since the words "police" or "firefighter" in an organization's name don't guarantee any actual department members are involved, and not all such organizations offer deductible donations. Child sponsorship programs vary in structure too: some direct funds to community-wide projects rather than the specific sponsored child, which isn't a problem in itself, but it's worth understanding which model you're supporting. And if you're giving to a local chapter of a national charity, don't assume your gift stays local or that the chapter's finances mirror the national office's; check the local chapter's own standing separately.

Back to top